Monday, March 23, 2009

Millcreek's Fading Civility




I'm going to break from my customary style and comment on something not directly related to higher education or learning (although I do think those of us in that field can learn something from the situation I will describe here).

I grew up in East Millcreek, a small township southeast of Salt Lake City, Utah.  Millcreek was settled by Mormon pioneers who were drawn to the area by the resources of the creek that flows from the nearby Canyon (now known as Millcreek Canyon).  The area gained its name because of the variety of mills that sprang up along the creek.  It was these mills and the local orchards that supported the families that settled in Millcreek.  These were hard-working, blue-collar families that relied upon the creek and each other to survive.  In talking to long-time residents of the community (many who remember the days of operating mills and large orchards) there is very real sense that early Millcreek residents understood what it meant to be a neighbor.  They believed very strongly that how they lived their invidual lives and the decisions they made, had an impact upon the family down the road and the community as a whole.  

Millcreek has changed quite drastically in the last 10 years.  Because of good schools, quiet streets, and beautiful views of the foothills (among many other things) more and more people are "discovering" the area and purchasing homes.  This is a good thing.  Communities need new members and the ideas, young energy, and vibrancy they bring with them.  However, when an individual or family relocates to a new city or neighborhood, they are not just purchasing a new home, but becoming part of a new community.  With this comes a responsibility to seek to understand the history, traditions, and culture of that community.  That isn't to say that new members of a group should blindly accept all practices of that community (otherwise, how would meaningful change ever occur?), but there is value in "fitting in" without losing ones own unique identity or sacrificing all of one's own interests.  At the same time, existing members have a responsibility to be open to the new ideas, interests, and needs of its new members.

So, what does this all mean for East Millcreek?  I won't take the time to outline the current dispute among Millcreek residents (for more information see this Salt Lake Tribune Article for January 26, 2009).  In a nutshell, residents are divided over the issue of whether or not homeowners should be restricted in the size of homes that they build.  One group believes that home owners should have ultimate freedom to do what they want with their land, another wants to place restrictions on the size of homes that can be built in the township. 

 As I have observed all of this play out in the newspapers and among neighbors in my old neighborhood it has been a sad commentary on how we view community.  Essentially, we have become incredibly selfish.  In terms of the current issue in Millcreek, that selfishness is seen on both sides--it's just manifested in different ways.  Whether it is a new move-in acting in complete disregard to their neighbors and building an over-sized home that blocks sight lines and becomes an eyesore, or a long-time resident that refuses to acknowledge that a home built in 1945 may not meet the needs of a young family of 2009, the malady is the same--complete disregard for others.

For the record, I'm in favor of some sort of restriction and have a hard time swallowing the argument that the size of some homes in Millcreek prevent families from growing or expanding (I'm not a demographer, but my sense is that family size has decreased in the last 40-50 years so a need for larger homes seems illogical).  But, my own personal biases aside, I hope that Millcreek's citizens will step back and remember what it used to mean to be part of a neighborhood or community--dialogue, sharing, and compromise.

In terms of higher education, I think we see this same sort of demise on our campuses.  Generally, we have become very fragmented and siloed academic cities of sorts.   We make decisions unilaterally, have given up on building relationships across departments/colleges, and mostly think of our own well-being.    For recent examples of this sort of thing see the two Inside Higher Ed articles below:


I don't have any real good solutions, but a start would be exploring the work of Bob Putnam in Better Together.  Putnam outlines a handful of successful communities and there are valuable lessons to be learned from these case studies.  Additionally, if any readers have made it to the end of this much longer than intended post and have examples of successfully functioning communities, I would love to hear about them.  Like Putnam, I still have hope that we can build and sustain effective communities, but recognize that they are becoming increasingly harder to find.  


Thursday, March 19, 2009

Underprepared & Underaware

I've been doing some work lately that has caused me to revisit a theme that I was quite fascinated with a few years ago.

In "Unskilled and Unaware of it" James Kruger and David Dunning describe a phenomenon whereby individuals with incompetence in some area (humour, writing, etc.) are unable to detect their own incompetence because of a lack of metacognitive ability about the particular skill or ability in question.  This has some interesting applications in education and students' willingness to engage in the process.

If they are incompetent in any of a number of academic areas, but don't know that, how receptive will they be to new opportunities to learn?  Will they engage?

James Prochaska's Transtheoretical Model (particularly the "Stages of Change" he identified with Norcross) has some interesting connections to these ideas as well.  If an individual is at a very early level in terms of their "readiness for change" how do they respond to efforts like first-year initiatives that seek to change academic attitudes and behaviours.  What risk do we run when we try to engage students that aren't ready to change?

Expect some more on this in the coming months.  I'm working on a paper and conference presentation exploring these issues.

Tuesday, March 10, 2009

Ritual in Education


For a great example of using ritual, see Washington State's Convocation highlights.

In a past posting I discussed the role of "Celebration" in learning.  Here, I address a somewhat related issue:  how the "rituals" on our campuses can be viewed as pedagogical tools.  

In an article that appeared in Anthropology & Education Quarterly ("The Campus Tour:  Ritual and community in higher education",2000), Peter Magolda analyzes the campus tour given at Miami University (OH) and uses it as a context for discussing the role of ritual on our college campuses.  His thoughts about how rituals convey messages and values struck me as very important.  His suggestion to educators is to closely examine the rituals on our campuses--from large rituals like Graduation to small "interaction" rituals like the way a campus tour guide addresses tour participants--to learn about what kinds of messages we are sending.  His premise is that students, particularly prospective and new students, learn a great deal about the institution and its "way" by observing and participating in these rituals.  

From my perspective educators responsible for administering new student programs (orientation, registration, common reading programs, guidebooks, etc.) could do a great deal more to include thoughtful rituals in their work.  My reasons are below:

1.  Rituals model appropriate behaviours and attitudes.  One "ritual" that is quite common in New Student Orientation programming is some sort of academic session often led by a faculty member.  Often these sessions are intended to help students understand what a college course is like, including how they might be different than what they have experienced in high school.  Many institutions are beginning to use these sessions as a means of discussing a common reading book as well.  Rituals like these provide excellent opportunities to model academic dialogue, classroom decorum, strategies for learning, etc.  An example would be the way in which Appalachian State University uses it's "Phase 2" orientation as a venue for small group discussions about that year's common reading text.  These discussions are meant to "simulate the manner in which many university level discussion classes are conducted."  Additionally, by inviting students to read the book prior to arriving in Boone for orientation, the institution notifies students of the expectation that they will come to class and other academic discussions prepared to make a meaningful contribution.  Then, at orientation they have a chance to actually participate in this ritual, further reinforcing institutional values of preparedenss, dialogue, and meaning-making.  The training of discussion leaders seems critical in all of this because the comments they make and stories they share (much like the way a tour guide functions) are likely to shape students attitudes and expectations.

2.  Rituals set expectations & communicate values.  New students learn a great deal about what is normal or appropriate based on what they observe during "ritualistic" activities.  For example, the campus tour and the dialogue embedded within it (both formal scripts and informal comments that may be made during the course of the tour) convey to students a sense of what is valued and celebrated.  If a tour guide says a great deal about undergraduate research opportunities, the excellent resources in the library, or showcases classroom space, students will infer that academic work and serious learning are important aspects of the experience of students at that institution.  Likewise, a tour guide who highlights great clubs, the best burger joints, or the best places to meet dates sends a message about the importance of social interactions.  Both messages may be appropriate, the important thing is that institutions examine their rituals to learn more about what types of messages are being sent.  If an institution expects that students will make the library a home away from home, this message should be implicit in one or more of its rituals.  Or, if lively dialogue and debate are important on a campus, rituals highlighting these behaviours should be very visible.

3.  Rituals build community.  Participating in rituals like convocation, the signing of a matriculation, or even attending a campus athletic event signal to students that they have become members of the campus community.  That said, care needs to be taken to ensure that the rituals included in new student programs are not systematically marginalizing sub-populations of the incoming class (e.g. those that are not interested in athletics).  Even then, I believe that administrators can be thoughtful enough about the types and varieties of rituals embraced that participation in orientation activities and other first-year programming can lead to a sense of community for new students.  


The bottom line is that our institutions have both espoused theories and theories in use (see John Tagg's work in The Learning Paradigm College).  Too often our espoused theories (Tagg would say these are the things that show up in glossy brochures and guide books) are not reinforced in the day-to-day operations of our universities.  I would argue that this is especially true of many of our rituals, particularly the small "interaction" rituals that Magolda describes in his article.  It is through these often unplanned, informal, and relatively brief interactions that students may learn the most about what we value and what we hope they will value as members of our academic community.   



Monday, March 2, 2009

Democracy & Salvation

hIn my blog reading this morning I came across some thoughts posted by David Gagnon about democracy, Christianity, and education.  David talked of how new media and web 2.0 technology ("participatory media" I think he called it) have provided opportunities to become world citizens by participating in a global dialogue.  He also spoke of how this participation can be a means of "salvation", which was very intriguing.  I'm not sure that I understand perfectly what he meant by drawing that connection between democratic participation and salvation, but I thought I would articulate some of my thoughts here as an attempt to clarify my thinking.  

It's a little odd to use the two words that appear in the title of this posting together because we generally associate "democracy" with matters of state and "salvation" obviously has some religious connotations.  However, the roots of the idea of "cosmopolitanism" in Greek history suggest that there may be far more parallels to the two worlds than we are willing to admit.  Cosmopolitanism as the greeks used it referred to the belief that an individual was not just a member of the Athenian community or a particulary greek city-state; rather, he was a member of the global community--a "citizen of the world".  This had implications for the way he used his time, knowledge, and skill because he had a unique role to play in the global community and a responsibility to do his part to contribute and make an improvement in whatever way he could.

This idea of continual improvement, albeit through small individual contributions, resonates with me and seems to capture, in part, the idea of salvation that I espouse (that humans posess an innate ability for continual or eternal improvement and that it is in this incremental growth that we can find true happiness).  The opportunities for world-wide discourse that have become a reality with recent advances in technology seem to have an important role to play in this idea of democratic salvation, wherein we work together as a global community to improve our lives and the state of the society that we live in.  

By participating in this global dialogue and voicing our thoughts, ideas, and opinions we provide an opportunity for others to hear our thoughts and be changed or impacted by them.  Granted, much of what is said in an online environment, be it blogs, wikis, etc. isn't likely to be earth-shattering or life-changing (although that might happen at times).  However, I do believe that by continually exposing ourselves to the ideas of others, and then reflecting on them personally, we move towards a closer approximation of truth and are better positioned to live lives of meaning.  Open education has some interesting implications here as well.  Those that are working to provide these sorts of opportunities are providing "saving" opportunities (because of what increased education and knowledge mean for the quality of an indiviual's life and the lives of his/her family) by providing access to learning.  It's hard for me to see how those sorts of opportunities wouldn't "save" lives.  

This is all very rough thinking, so I apologize if it's unclear.  If anyone has thoughts relative to these ideas, please share.  I'm interested in pursuing this, but need some help.


Tuesday, February 24, 2009

Celebration as Learning

At the recent FYE Conference in Orlando, Kurt Penner from Kwantlen Polytechnic University in Vancouver, British Columbia presented a session on how First-Year Experience programs can use "celebration" as a supplement to their offerings, particularly at the end of the first year.  This got me thinking about how celebration could be used as a pedagogical tool so I started a small conversation among colleagues in Utah where I work and live.  The general consensus was that celebration might be a good thing, but it would depend on how it is done.  

One comment in our discussion was particularly thought provoking.  Gary Daynes, a friend and the Associate Provost for Integrative Learning at Westminster College in Salt Lake City, Utah raised questions about how meaningless most celebrations have become and used the myriad award shows that we see on TV these days.  While I would agree that most of the award ceremonies that we see in the media (think of the Oscars the other night where 25 awards were given, but most of us really only cared about 5 of them--and how many Americans even know what "cinematography" is?) have become dog and pony shows, I do believe that strategic and intentional celebrations can lead to meaningful learning and reflection for students.  My reasons are outlined below:

1.  Ritualistic closure presents opportunities for learning and growth.  Effective celebrations become rituals that, when timed in a strategic way, can bring closure to a meaningful experience while also serving as a springboard for what is to come, or the "next step" as it were.  Commencement exercises at colleges and universities are an excellent example of this.  During commencement students celebrate the end of their academic journey, are reminded of various aspects of the experience (e.g. challenges faced/overcome, knowledge gained, relationships developed), and then invited to consider how their 4 years of scholarship have prepared them to "commence" the next step in their journey, whether that is graduate school, work, raising a family, or anything else they might choose to do.  I may be going out on a limb with this one, but a marriage might also be considered a ritualistic celebration that "closes" one chapter and promotes reflection on the next--a couple celebrate the end of their courtship, recall experiences they have had together and the characteristics they value in each other, and then look forward to their future life together.  Well-timed and thoughtful rituals like these and others bring tremendous opportunities for reflection, meaning-making, and learning.  Even more, it isn't empty learning that is stored away on a shelf--the participants are engaged in considering how what they have learned or experienced makes a difference in what they will do and become.  (For a thoughtful discussion of the role rituals play on college campuses, you might consider reading Peter Magolda's essay in Anthropology & Education Quarterly)

2.  Celebrations can recognize and reinforce behaviours that lead to good learning.  When student/faculty awards are included in first-year celebrations, organizers help stakeholders involved in the first-year to identify and consider those behaviours that promote deep and meaningful learning.  This is an appropriate time to reconsider the Oscars as a poor example of this sort of celebration.  The problem with award ceremonies in Hollywood is that (1) there are far too many awards given, effectively decreasing the prestige of all but the top awards (e.g. best actor/actress, etc.) and (2) those giving the awards don't articulate clearly why a particular actress or film is being recognized so unless someone has seen the film and has some film background they never really learn what, for example, good sound editing looks (or sounds) like.  Effective celebrations not only recognize good performance, but help the rest of the community better understand why the performance is good.  Hearing well-told stories about individuals being recognized (stories that highlight the behaviours we wish to reinforce) are a good way of driving this sort of learning.

3.  Celebration builds community.  Bringing students together to celebrate one another's achievements, hear stories about challenges and struggles, and recognize meaningful learning can connect them to each other and to our campuses.  These interactions can remind members of the campus community of our shared experiences and encourage us to support one another as we move towards becoming communities of scholars.  Ritualistic practices like fight songs, iconic images from campus, stories about founders, etc. also help revive feelings of pride and respect for the institution.  Things like this frequently occur at our orientations and again at graduation, but there is a dearth of such practices in the gap between those two bookends.  While large gatherings like what occur at the two ends of the college experience are things that probably cannot and should not be replicated.  Smaller-scale celebrations during the "in-between" times could enhance the sense of community on campuses.

4.  Celebrations communicate messages about what an institution values.  When an institution invites members of its community to gather together for a common experience, it communicates a set of values to the participants.  Furthermore, students learn about what we value by the number and type of gatherings we promote.  Consider the gatherings we see most often on the campuses of large research universities.  While only anecdotal, the three types of celebrations I see are athletic events, faculty lectures focused on research, and large-scale social events that feel like parties.  None of these things are inherently negative; however, when students see these celebrations they learn about what the institution values:  high-profile athletics, scholarly work, and "good times".  With no celebrations of student learning to balance the rest of our celebrations, there is danger that students will pick up on the theory in use (John Tagg, The Learning Paradigm College, 2003) and lose sight of our true institutional missions (Tagg would call this the espoused theory)--learning and becoming.  Effective academic celebrations will communicate to students that we value meaningful learning, effort, civic engagement that draws upon the knowledge we gain at our institutions, and the overcoming of challenges.  

What does all of this mean?
The answer that comes to my mind immediately is "I don't know" because the implications of these ideas probably look very different depending on what campus we might find ourselves on (I also recognize that there are a lot of flaws in my thinking surrounding this issue and hesitate to make any broad statements about what should happen on any given campus, especially my own).  With that disclaimer, I do believe that we could be a little more thoughtful about the celebrations we design for our first-year students.  I've outlined some basic principles that might be helpful--embedded rituals, recognition of good learning, and institutional values--so I won't say much more about those things, but I would like to close with a warning.  As faculty and administrators, there is a danger that the celebrations we design will become what students might see as "too academic".  It is important that these celebrations are at least a little bit like the celebrations we experience outside of our jobs (e.g. birthdays, parties, etc.).  That's not to say that these celebrations should look or feel like what we already see on our campuses (the ones planned by Student Affairs units where we give out lots of free food and play loud music).  As academic affairs professionals we have a responsibility to find a balance where the celebrations we organize are enjoyable enough that people will actually come, but thoughtful enough that they really lead to learning.  As far as I can tell we have lots to do in that area.  



Tuesday, February 17, 2009

Helping Students Create a "Digital Identity"

I recently returned from the Annual Conference of the National Resource Center for the First-Year Experience and Students in Transition held Feb. 6-10 in Orlando, Florida.  I was struck by the frequency with which web 2.0 technologies (blogs, wikis, social networking sites, etc.) are being used as pedagogical and community-building tools in first-year initiatives across the country.

In one of the very first sessions I attended Kevin Prentiss, CEO of Swift Kick (an education company specializing in open and collaborative learning, particularly using technology in meaningful ways to support learning and engagement) said something that has had me thinking ever since.  He talked about the importance of helping students create a "digital identity" that can serve as an educational footprint, documenting what they have learned, what conversations they have been participants in, what they have produced, etc.  Those working in higher ed might describe this as an e-portfolio (something that we have been discussing on my campus).  
Basically, the idea is that as educators we should be inviting and encouraging students to be active participants in the blogosphere by creating and maintaining blogs, commenting on the blogs of others, posting material to their blogs that demonstrates meaningful learning, etc.  

This was a completely new idea to me.  I had heard lots of negative things about students involvement with blogs & social networking sites, but never have I heard an argument for using these technologies as well articulated and clear as the one Kevin presented.  I can see a number of reasons why we as educators should promote blogging and e-portfolios among students

1.  Students like technology and know how to use it well.  Students live in a fast-paced and dynamic world.  They are accustomed to being engaged by technology that employs a variety of media and are becoming increasingly uninterested in static forms of learning (e.g. sitting in large lecture halls, searching the stacks for periodicals, etc.).  While arguments for "traditional" aspects of education can be made and definitely have value in some cases, the reality is that if education does not adapt to present itself in a way that is engaging for students, they will go somewhere else to learn (on a side note, open learning is making that easier and more viable as we speak).  Good teaching involves finding ways to engage the unique learners that present themselves to us.  By refusing to use technology in meaningful ways we are limiting the learning that might occur, and as a result, guilty of educational malpractice.

2.  E-Portfolios can simpflify and improve assessment.  Imagine what it would be like for a university to have electronic collections of students writing, research, poetry, film creations, etc?  Even more, using blogs and other open electronic tools means that we spend less on paper, filing, human resources, etc.  Obviously, institutions would need to be thoughtful about how to organize e-portfolios so that they were searchable, findable, etc., but if we are as insightful and bright as we all think we are in higher ed, we should be able to figure something out.  The point is that if institutions made campus-wide efforts to employ web 2.0 technologies the educational record of their students would grow rapidly and provide meaningful assessment artifacts.

3.  Learning should be a knowledge-building enterprise.  Students who are engaged in creating knowledge are better learners.  This is not a new idea, however, at times we fence ourselves in by thinking that all knowledge construction consists of written papers and exams.  Blogs, wikis, etc. provide additional opportunities for students to share, refine, and construct new knowledge in ways not always possible through traditional assessment instruments.  Electronic forums not only allow students to write, but they can also create and share images, engage with video content, reference web-based materials, etc.  While reading and writing do form the backbone of education, there are a whole host of other ways to learn, many of which are neglected in higher education.

4.  Learning should be a social and open process.  The best learning occurs as individuals engage in dialogue with each other.  While this dialogue may make cameos in our undergraduate experience, the reality is that most undergraduate students pack themselves into large or small rooms and listen to monologues.  Occasional class discussions may ensue but they are all too often directed by an authority figure (the instructor), limited to a pre-determined set of topics or questions, and limited by physical space and time (e.g. when the 90 minute class session is over, so is the conversation).  Electronic media provide opportunities for students to engage in discussions long after the session ends, about whatever they want, and in whatever manner or sequence they see fit.  While this may scare some people ("what will the prisoners do if we let them out into the yard for free time?"), the potential benefits cannot be ignored.  The challenge for educators is to help students see the value in these dialogues and to generate enough motivation for them to engage in the process.  I'm convinced that after one or two meaningful learning experiences in this setting, students will be "converted" and participate of their own accord thereafter.  Additionally, these conversations can occur across courses and student cohorts (e.g. poly sci students may talk with biology students about environmental issues, athletes may read and comment on the blogs of dietetics students, etc.) leading to the development of a true community of scholars where learning knows no disciplinary or classroom bounds.

In short, using collaborative, conversational technologies in meaningful ways will not only create this digital identity for students, which as an aside makes them much more attractive to employers who are in the habit of "googling" applicants to see what kind of contribution they have made in the blogosphere, but has the potential to provide a much more meaningful and engaging learning experience while they are on our campuses.

For a much more thoughtful and articulate discussion of this and other ideas, visit Swift Kick's blog at http://blog.swiftkickonline.com/.


Friday, February 6, 2009

Teachers: Does pay make a difference?

In a recent "Inside HigherEd" column Wicke Sloane (a candidate for the presidency at Williams College) commented about the pay of university administrators by saying 

"For a job you love, and that’s what a college presidency must be, $125,000, house or not, is an awful lot of money. I disagree that colleges will only attract able presidents by offering vast salaries and benefits. Today, high salaries may attract exactly the wrong candidates."


That got me thinking about the way that we pay teachers.  Not that there is any danger in this ever happening in my lifetime, but what would happen if teachers were paid like attorneys or business executives?  Would we attract the "wrong candidates" like Sloane suggests?  What is the magic salary window in which we attract the "right" candidates?

In my home state of Utah most first-year public school teachers make around $28,000.  In the district where I taught I was paid $26,000 for my first year, but other districts are a bit higher.  Like many young professionals in the field, particularly those with families, I made the decision to leave public education because the prospect of supporting a family, going on any sort of vacation, and ever buying a home seemed very out of reach.  This may sound a bit arrogant, but I considered myself an excellent educator and feel like the system lost a good candidate when I left.  This is the current debate in education:  How much do we need to pay in order to keep the talented ones?

I'm not really sure what that number is, although it is surely more than what we are paying teachers currently.  The interesting question is the one posed by Sloane.  How much is too much?  How important is altruism and unselfishness in a teacher?  Does paying them what they are worth pose a threat to their motives and intentions?  It's interesting to me that we ask these sorts of questions relative to education, but not in other fields like, say for instance medicine.  My wife recently delivered our first child and I was shocked at what the anesthesiologist made (grateful that we had him, but still quite amazed at what he billed for the limited amount of time he spent attending to my wife).  For the record, I think his services are worth what we pay him for.  What is interesting to me is that I don't think anyone would ever worry about what his pay might do in terms of his motives or whether the high pay of the position might attract the "wrong" type of candidate.

Is attracting the "wrong" type of candidate really something we should be worrying about?